By Melanie Catania
Published: Nov. 26, 2004

When we experience an illusion, we usually have the impression we have been fooled, or that our minds are playing tricks on us. New research published in the Oct. 31 issue

Photo by Neil Brake Li Men Chen, left, Anna Roe and Robert Friedman

of the journal Science indicates our perceptions of these illusions are no hoax, but the result of how the brain is organized to process the information it receives from our senses.

Vanderbilt University psychology department researchers Anna Wang Roe, Li Min Chen and Robert Friedman have identified responses in the brain to a touch illusion that shed new light on how the brain processes sensory information and call into question long-held theories about the nature of the “map” of the body in the brain.

Walter Penfield is credited with first establishing in 1957 that a map of the human body exists in the brain, with specific areas of the cortex processing information from different body areas. Researchers have long hypothesized this map is a topographic map of the physical body.

	Photo by Neil Brake Li Min Chen

“What is surprising about this paper is we found the cortical map reflects our perceptions, not the physical body,” Roe said. “The brain is reflecting what we are feeling, even if that’s not what really happened.” The team completed the research at Yale University before moving to Vanderbilt this fall.

Roe’s research used a well-documented illusion called the tactile funneling illusion to explore how the brain processes touch. With this illusion, an individual perceives simultaneous touches to multiple locations on an area of skin as a single touch at the center of that area. Although the perception of this illusion has been studied for decades, researchers did not know how it was processed by the brain.

Photo by Neil Brake Anna Roe demonstrates the use of the camera and apparatus used for intrinsic signal optical imaging.

Roe’s team first tested the funneling illusion in humans by stimulating adjacent fingers. The human subjects confirmed that they experienced a sensation between the two fingers when both were touched simultaneously. The team then used a technique called intrinsic signal optical imaging to study the reaction to the same illusion in the brains of squirrel monkeys. Intrinsic signal optical imaging uses a specially designed video camera to detect changes in light reflectance viewed through a “window on the brain.” These cortical reflectance changes are related to changes in blood flow that occur when neurons respond to specific sensory stimuli.

When the monkeys were touched on one digit alone, the researchers observed a response in Area 3b of the somatosensory cortex, the area previously determined to process information from that digit. When an adjacent digit was stimulated on its own, a response was seen in the cortical map for that digit. However, when the monkey was

	Area 3b of the squirrel monkey brain

touched simultaneously on both digits, a single cortical location between the maps of the two individual digits responded, explaining the perceived location of the illusion. In addition, the perceived intensity of this illusion is caused by the integration of activity across all three locations (two actual, one illusory).

In addition to establishing that the cortical map reflects perception rather than physical location, the researchers found the brain processes touch perceptions at an unexpectedly early stage.

Images a, c, e and g illustrate the places in area 3b known to correspond to digits four (D4), three (D3) and two (D2) in the squirrel monkey. In image b the area outlined in red is activated when the D2 digit is stimulated alone. In image d, the area outlined in yellow is activated when digit D3 is stimulated alone. In image f the area outlined in green is activated when digit D4 is stimulated alone. When digits D3 and D4 are stimulated at the same time, however, a new area – outlined in red in image h – is activated. This new area is between the areas associated with D3 and D4 and includes portions of each.

“The cortical area we studied, 3b, is an early entry level in the cortex for information from the skin,” said Friedman. “We did not expect to see perception being reflected that early. This gives us a much better understanding of how much work the brain is doing, even at this early level of processing.”

Photo by Neil Brake Robert Friedman tests the funneling illusion on a human subject by stimulating adjacent fingers.

“How we perceive the world is an enduring question in neuroscience,” Mriganka Sur, head of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences, said. “This is a fascinating study that cleverly uses a tactile illusion to demonstrate that the brain's representations of the world, and of sensory stimuli that impinge on us, are shaped by the brain's circuitry. In short, our perceptions have a great deal to do with the way our brains are wired.”

Roe’s team will continue to study how the brain processes sensory input and illusions, though Roe cautions against misinterpretation of that term. “Illusions are not unusual or strange—they are how we interpret the world,” Roe said. “We think we know what’s out there in the physical world, but it’s all interpreted by our brains. Everything we sense is an illusion to a degree.”

-VU-

Anna Roe’s home page

Science article “Optical Imaging of a Tactile Illusion in Area 3b of the Primary Somatosensory Cortex” [subscription required]